Atalanta forward Ademola Lookman has strongly rebuked his manager, Gian Piero Gasperini, for publicly criticizing him after a missed penalty in Atalanta’s 3-1 UEFA Champions League defeat against Club Brugge.
Lookman, who had stepped up in a crucial moment, found himself on the receiving end of Gasperini’s harsh remarks, labeling him as the “worst penalty taker.”
Such public condemnation has raised serious questions about Gasperini’s sense of sportsmanship and collective responsibility as a leader.
Instead of fostering a team spirit and supporting his players, the Italian tactician’s comments have sparked controversy over his ability to lead with fairness and professionalism.
In a strongly worded statement on Wednesday, Lookman expressed his disappointment at being singled out, emphasizing that his commitment to the team had never wavered.
“Being singled out in the manner I have been not only hurts but feels deeply disrespectful, not least because of the immense hard work and commitment I have always put in each and every day to help bring success to this club and the incredible fans of Bergamo,” Lookman said.
A Coach’s Role: Critique or Condemnation?
A football manager’s role extends beyond mere tactical decisions; it involves fostering an environment where players can thrive. Publicly ridiculing a player is the antithesis of leadership, particularly in a sport that thrives on team unity and morale.
Lookman clarified that he had not acted out of turn by taking the penalty, explaining that the club’s designated penalty taker had entrusted him with the responsibility at that moment.
“During the match, the designated penalty taker instructed me to take the penalty; and to support the team, I took responsibility in the moment to do so,” Lookman explained.
Given these facts, Gasperini’s decision to single him out in the aftermath seems not only unfair but a poor display of sportsmanship. As a coach, it is Gasperini’s duty to shield his players from excessive criticism, not to expose them to unnecessary scrutiny.
A History of Unfair Criticism?
This is not the first time Gasperini’s approach to leadership has come into question. Throughout his tenure at Atalanta, he has displayed an authoritarian style that has sometimes alienated his players rather than inspiring them. Public criticism can demoralize a player, rather than encouraging them to improve.
The Nigerian international has been an instrumental part of Atalanta’s success, notably helping the club to a Europa League triumph last May. Despite this, he has endured difficult moments within the club, always prioritizing the team’s success over personal grievances.
“In truth, I have dealt with many difficult moments during my time here—the majority of which I have never spoken about because, in my opinion, the team must always be protected and must come first. This makes what happened last night even more hurtful,” Lookman added.
Sportsmanship in Modern Football
Gasperini’s comments raise broader concerns about professionalism in football management. Criticism of a player should be constructive, not a public spectacle.
True leadership means standing by your players, especially in challenging moments.
When teams suffer setbacks, a strong leader takes responsibility rather than shifting blame onto individuals.
Gasperini’s remarks suggest a lack of self-awareness, as well as an unwillingness to accept his own role in Atalanta’s performance.
The Way Forward
Atalanta’s success hinges not only on tactical prowess but also on fostering a healthy team dynamic. Managers like Gasperini should recognize the importance of collective responsibility and the impact their words can have on a player’s confidence.
Instead of public criticism, offering support and guidance behind closed doors is the mark of a true leader.
Football is a team sport, and victories—as well as defeats—should be shouldered together.
Gasperini’s approach risks damaging team morale, which could have far-reaching consequences for Atalanta’s future performances.
Lookman’s response highlights the emotional toll of being unfairly singled out. His professionalism in addressing the issue contrasts sharply with Gasperini’s public outburst.
The incident serves as a reminder that leadership in football is about more than tactics—it’s about respect, encouragement, and accountability. If Atalanta hopes to maintain its standing in European football, its coach must adopt a more constructive approach to player management.
True sportsmanship lies in standing with your team through victories and setbacks alike. Gasperini’s comments have not only disrespected Lookman but also questioned his own ability to foster a truly united squad.
